Disclaimer: Dieser Thread wurde aus dem alten Forum importiert. Daher werden eventuell nicht alle Formatierungen richtig angezeigt. Der ursprüngliche Thread beginnt im zweiten Post dieses Threads.
Homework week 13 (due 19-01-2016)
For this week’s homework do the assignment for week 13; the review for week 12 was skipped. There was a mail sent before the holidays and there are some threads here describing the assignment, plus the homework spreadsheet was updated.
We had one report that a student uploaded a review after adding a grade and a placeholder textual review but could not see the uploaded file except when trying to do a new upload. Clicking the link on the file then gave an ‘unauthorized’ message. I confirmed that the student’s PDF review was indeed uploaded, so when you have this situation of being unauthorized to view your upload you can be reasonably sure that your file was uploaded, even if Crowdgrader doesn’t allow you to view it (I will report this problem to the Crowdgrader developers).
If you encounter an empty assignment (we have been informed there is one) simply give it a 0 and leave placeholder text, and go on to review another submissions.
Maybe I missed it when it was mentioned last class, but: Can we write more than a page for the review of our fellow students’ papers? I feel like I could help more than just with one page.
Edit:
The same happens for me and it also says „Review attachment: None“, still on the overview page there is a clickable „Attached file“-Link.
But I guess it’s the same situation as you described.
I think it’s okay to make it more than one page because a detailed and thoughtful review is helpful to the student who wrote the paper.
In practice, the academic reviews you receive would rarely exceed one page, but also the reviewer is receiving a polished submission and largely critiquing the scientific work. In the case of the student project work this is the first draft rather than the final version, so there may be more scope for providing somewhat broader feedback than you typically would in an academic review.
Just remember to adhere to the academic review style in your review.
I can confirm that there is a PDF upload for your review.